Accessible Authentication (Enhanced)
A cognitive function test (such as remembering a password or solving a puzzle) is not required for any step in an authentication process unless that step provides an alternative authentication method that does not rely on a cognitive function test, or a mechanism is available to assist the user in completing the cognitive function test.
In plain language
This is a stricter version of the accessible authentication rule (3.3.8). No authentication step can require someone to remember or work something out on their own, and that includes tasks like "pick the photos with a car in them." There must always be an alternative that doesn't depend on memory or reasoning, like biometrics or a support mechanism.
Why it matters
Tests like remembering a password or recognizing objects in images (CAPTCHA-style) exclude people with cognitive, memory, or learning disabilities, even when some kind of help is offered. This version guarantees a login path that doesn't depend on that kind of mental effort.
In practice
Fails this criterion
To confirm identity, the site asks the user to select all the images containing a car (CAPTCHA-style), and offers no other login method.
Meets this criterion
The site lets people sign in with fingerprint or face recognition on their phone or computer, or with a password manager that fills in their credentials. The person never has to remember or solve anything on their own.
Test it yourself
Go through the site's login and identity-verification flow. If at any point the only option is to remember and type a password or solve a visual test (like picking images), with no alternative such as biometrics or a password manager, this criterion is failing.